Steven W, 2014-01-21 00:43 »
I was going to write about this some time ago, but decided not to. Your post reminded me of it, Charlotte. Several years ago, I was running a Kubuntu distro. Of course I wanted to be able to play MP3s and watch Flash videos, so I got the "restricted extras" enabling all of that. Big warnings, a click-through dialog, yada, yada. Well after a while I decided to try out Amarok. Well it installs no issue, but I realize quickly it's tied up with 1.fm. So, I'm thinking to myself let's give out warnings that we're downloading proprietary stuff, but when we link up with third-party, for-profit, commercial entities -- nothing. Went to the KDE forums and I'll be the first to admit, I could've done a better job getting the point across, at least at first. Well after several posts, I think my point was finally made. I didn't necessarily want the functionality just gone, but felt that it should be an "add-on" that was a few clicks away. The invariable "OMG Amarok devs don't take away 1.fm functionality or the sky will fall" post had to be put in there too. Again, not what I was saying, just questioning the comfort level with this third-party stuff. Well end result was that the devs felt it was up to the distros to decide how to handle it. I'm not going to say this was either correct or incorrect. I have to admit they did walk me through removing it, and the files that I deleted, could easily have been set up in a separate download.
I don't wanna give the impression that I'm singling out KDE/Amarok or Ubuntu/Kubuntu for this. I could, now, point out quite a few open source programs you could download that are, *by default*, compiled with commercial third-party links/support built in to them. I know you're speaking of MS, Charlotte. Windows Media Player 7.x and above come to mind. Facebook APIs (Jesus Fucking Christ). I think the younger (de)generation has come to accept this crap as a norm.
I was going to write about this some time ago, but decided not to. Your post reminded me of it, Charlotte. Several years ago, I was running a Kubuntu distro. Of course I wanted to be able to play MP3s and watch Flash videos, so I got the "restricted extras" enabling all of that. Big warnings, a click-through dialog, yada, yada. Well after a while I decided to try out Amarok. Well it installs no issue, but I realize quickly it's tied up with 1.fm. So, I'm thinking to myself let's give out warnings that we're downloading proprietary stuff, but when we link up with third-party, for-profit, commercial entities -- nothing. Went to the KDE forums and I'll be the first to admit, I could've done a better job getting the point across, at least at first. Well after several posts, I think my point was finally made. I didn't necessarily want the functionality just gone, but felt that it should be an "add-on" that was a few clicks away. The invariable "OMG Amarok devs don't take away 1.fm functionality or the sky will fall" post had to be put in there too. Again, not what I was saying, just questioning the comfort level with this third-party stuff. Well end result was that the devs felt it was up to the distros to decide how to handle it. I'm not going to say this was either correct or incorrect. I have to admit they did walk me through removing it, and the files that I deleted, could easily have been set up in a separate download.
I don't wanna give the impression that I'm singling out KDE/Amarok or Ubuntu/Kubuntu for this. I could, now, point out quite a few open source programs you could download that are, *by default*, compiled with commercial third-party links/support built in to them. I know you're speaking of MS, Charlotte. Windows Media Player 7.x and above come to mind. Facebook APIs (Jesus Fucking Christ). I think the younger (de)generation has come to accept this crap as a norm.